The First Unitarian Society of Westchester traces its roots to the 1850s, when Sunday services were held in a private Yonkers home. By 1856, growing crowds moved to the Getty House Lyceum, where Unitarians and Universalists alternated Sundays. In 1858 the congregation incorporated, and by 1861 dedicated a Gothic Revival church on North Broadway — home for over a century. In 1965, the congregation relocated to Hastings-on-Hudson, where it thrived for decades. Then came Hurricane Ida. In 2021, catastrophic flooding forced FUSW to leave its beloved home at 25 Old Jackson Avenue. It wasn't the first flood — a mid-1970s storm had famously required the minister to be rescued by police in a small boat — but Ida's damage was decisive. For over three years, the generous hospitality of South Presbyterian Church in Dobbs Ferry kept the congregation together.
A New Chapter
In April 2025, forty-three months after the flood, FUSW celebrated Easter Sunday in a brand new home — a beautiful sanctuary, a welcoming gathering space, and a modern pantry, all their own. The road was long, but the community held. And that, perhaps, is the truest reflection of who FUSW has always been.